Innocence Matters' Video Journal of Suzy's Case

Susan "Suzy" Mellen's Exoneration News

Katie Couric's Interview with Suzy, Deirdre, & Suzy's Family

In 1997, Susan Mellen, a mother of three, was falsely accused of committing the gruesome murder of Rick Daly.

At the time, Susan was living with her boyfriend, Tom, and her two youngest children, Jessica (9) and Donnie (7).  She was a gentle and doting mother, who succumbed to pressure to use methamphetamine in her early 30's.  She continued to use intermittently for the next 10 years.

In 1996, after her relationship with the kids' father end, Susan dated Rick Daly briefly.  Rick was good to her and her children; however, the relationship ended when Rick went to jail.  Susan met Tom in January 1997 and they had been dating for several months when Susan needed to move out of her mother's house.  Susan and her kids ultimately moved in with Tom in his Redondo Beach apartment. 

In July, Tom received notice that he was being evicted from the apartment, so Susan and Tom found a place a house in Gardena.  They picked up the keys on Sunday, July 20.  Tom worked the next day, so Susan, her daughter Jessica and Tom's father, Jim packed boxes and moved many of the smaller items in Susan's car and Jim's truck on the evening of July 21.  Susan was with Jessica all day and with Jim all evening.

Several miles away, three male Lawndale gang members were present in an abandoned house when one or more of them savagely attacked Rick Daly.

Mellen Case Timeline

7/21/97
  • 7:00 p.m. (approx.) - Daly last seen by girlfriend Cory
  • 10:30 p.m. - Daly's body found on fire in San Pedro Alley
8/2/97 thru 8/12/97
  • Numerous people told police Daly was killed by gang members, Ghost, Wicked, and Payaso
  • June Patti visited Wicked's mother several times
  • Wicked was arrested and charged with Daly's murder
  • Ghost and Payaso were arrested on unrelated cases but not questioned
8/13/97
  • 6:00 a.m. - Police raided home where suspected killers were staying
  • 9-11 a.m. - Patti took a deal on criminal charge for threatening her law enforcement sister while Winn interrogated Wicked's mother and others found in house
  • Afternoon - Patti tried to contact Detective Winn but could not get through; however, this was before Patti's "supposed" conversation with Susan
  • Afternoon - Ginger Wilborn was interrogated and told Winn that Wicked told her Wicked, Ghost and Payaso killed Daly
8/14/97
  • Morning - Patti attended Wicked's arraignment with Wicked's mother
  • 4:00 p.m. - Patti called Winn again and falsely claimed Susan told Patti about the murder
  • DA rejected filing on Ghost and Payaso because Winn's investigation did not yield sufficient evidence of their guilt
8/15/97
  • Morning - Patti spoke to Winn and falsely claimed that after a brief phone call with Susan on the evening of August 13 she and Susan met that night and Susan confessed to being present during Daly killing
8/25/97
  • Based solely on Patti's statement, Winn arrested Susan in front of her 9-year-old daughter
  • During an agressive police interrogation, Winn ignored Susan's repeated protestations of innocence and refused to give her a polygraph test 

Suzy's Bucket List

SupportSusanInnocenceMatters

 

  • Do the Running Man on Ellen's Show
  • Take a cruise with her family (and her favorite lawyer)
  • Share her story to help other innocent people
  • Teach her grandson to say "grandma"
  • Talk Donnie into moving back to California
  • Help plan Jessica's wedding
  • Reconnect with dear friends

Mellen Case Documents

Police Investigation

  • Police Report
  • June Patti's initial statement
  • June Patti's preliminary hearing testimony

Trial Transcripts

  • June Patti's testimony
  • Susan Mellen's testimony

Appellate Records

  • Appellate's Opening Brief
  • Respondent's Brief
  • Appellate's Reply Brief